SDX Trial Success
Testing screed types side-by-side in the badlands of North Dakota proves industry can increase density, improve ride with patterned screed, innovation, best practices.
By paving in echelon up and down the hills of Highway 85 in the North Unit of Theodore Roosevelt National Park (TRNP), the award-winning team of Central Specialties Inc., headquartered in Alexandria, Minnesota, tested densities and smoothness achieved behind the SDX screed plate design from Caterpillar alongside the traditional SE60 screed plate design. The crew performed this 10.214-lane-mile build in spring of 2024, achieving an average density improvement on the SDX lanes of 1.7% directly behind the screed and 1.2% after the finish rollers. The overall smoothness results paint a sustainable picture for the asphalt industry.
“We increased the density by 1 to 1.5% and ride by 10% behind the paver equipped with the SDX screed compared to the traditional one,” Bryce Wuori said. He’s the proprietor of Pavewise, headquartered in Bismarck, North Dakota, and was hired by Caterpillar to serve as a consultant on the project. “We saw a 25% decrease in standard deviation. The 10,000-foot view on this project was innovation and technologies that are pushing the industry forward can be proved with this data.”
The Theodore Roosevelt National Park is divided into three parts in western North Dakota, which include a South Unit and Elkhorn Ranch Unit. CSI paved in the North Unit in the spring of 2024.
Innovation Everywhere
Not only was the team using the innovative SDX screed plates on one of the pavers, but they also employed thermal mapping, intelligent compaction (IC) and multiple data-collection technologies to assess quality control/quality assurance (QC/QA) along the way.
One of the newer tools on hand was the GroundTruth system from Pavewise, which helped monitor environmental conditions in real time. This solar-powered, mini weather station was situated at the project site to communicate with the Pavewise software when inclement weather was rolling in. It also documented conditions for the team. For example, during southbound paving on May 29, the average ambient temperature was 64°F with an average wind speed of 9 miles per hour (MPH). That night, the area experienced 1.2 inches of rain. During northbound paving on May 30, the average ambient temperature was 57°F with an average wind speed of 11 MPH.
The CSI team executed paving both lifts of more than 12,000 total tons along the 10+ lane miles in two days.
The TRNP project in McKenzie County required paving 10+ total miles from the park entrance to County Road 30 (23rd Street NW). The crew was responsible for grading, aggregate base, hot-mix asphalt (HMA), culverts, box culvert, a pedestrian walking trail, the retaining wall, signage, pavement markings and incidentals. The mix design used on the project was North Dakota’s FAA45, which uses a PG64-34H binder. The CSI team produced the mix at its parallel-flow drum plant from CWMF, Waite Park, Minnesota, which was located outside Watford City. Typical production was 610 tons per hour with a propane-fueled Hauck Eco Star 200 burner. The average mix temperature out of the trucks was 306°F.
Belly-dump, live-bottom and tandem trailers delivered material ahead of two Weiler windrow elevator pickup machines, which in turn fed the two Cat AP1055F pavers with SE60 V-XW screeds vibrating at 1,200-1,400 VPM, and working in echelon.
“The paving widths were 18 feet behind the traditional screed AP1055 and 20 feet with 4-foot slough behind the 1055 with the SDX screed,” Wuori shared. See Figure 1 for more detail.
The base course was 2 inches compacted; the wearing course 1.5 inches compacted. Longitudinal joints were created with the notch wedge joint system from Willow Designs LLC, East Berlin, Pennsylvania. Jerod Willow, proprietor of Willow Designs, spoke to the efficacy of using a joint-making system with a vibrating screed.
“Screed vibration has no effect on the notch wedge device or produces no damage to the joint itself,” he said. “Willow Designs actually has options for electric vibrators on the notch wedge devices themselves because I believe using screed vibration is a good thing to a certain extent.”
Willow expanded on his theory and offered a tip for vibe settings. “Having screed vibration set at a moderate and manageable speed is key to help manipulate, turn and lock the aggregate in the asphalt mix together as it is protruded under the screed. A way to find manageable screed vibration per minute (VPM): stand a shovel on the catwalk of the paver screed. If it vibrates off and falls down, the VPM is too high.
“I believe too high screed VPM just causes excessive wear and tear on equipment with minimal results in increased mat density,” Willow continued. “Think about it like this: we are trying to keep the screed of the paver planted to the ground to assure a good ride quality of the pavement we are placing, but now using vibration at a high VPM is like having the screed of the paver do all these ‘micro jumps.’ Think about how vibration impacts work on roller drums. High VPM on the screed seems counterintuitive. From a highly technical standpoint, paver screeds should oscillate to be effective and produce minimal deviations of mat quality as far as smoothness and rideability.”
To assess mat temperature behind the screeds, the crew employed paver-mounted thermal profiling (PMTP). The SDX-equipped paver employed the Caterpillar thermal camera system, and it collected data showing the average lot temperature behind that screed was 267°F. It also showed a low to moderate incidence of thermal segregation. The traditional paver employed the MOBA thermal camera system, and it collected data showing the average lot temperature behind the traditional screed was 259°F. It also showed a moderate to high incidence of thermal segregation. Wuori indicated: “Thermal consistency behind the SDX produced a lower thermal segregation index than the traditional screed.”
He explained: “The 3D textured surface of the SDX screed kneads the aggregate together, forcing it to move into position. This action develops more density and thermal consistency behind the screed with this manipulation.”
Multiple steel drum Cat rollers equipped with intelligent compaction (IC) and Versa-Vibe worked in breakdown, intermediate and finish positions to achieve compaction. The IC used included a CB-460 display with Trimble Systems, VRS positioning data and WorksOS. Each of these provided the operator with a means to track passes, temperatures and impacts-per-foot to ensure the highest quality of rolling was being achieved on the project.
For the SDX-equipped paver, the rollers were a Cat CB15 in breakdown position and another Cat CB15 in the intermediate position. For the traditional-screed paver, the rollers were a Cat CB66 in breakdown position and another Cat CB66 in the intermediate position. Both paving lanes shared a Cat CB15 in static mode in the finish position.
Paving team Bradley and Jill O’Brien are a married couple who handled compaction behind the SDX screed plate. Jill operates the breakdown roller while Brad operates the intermediate and finish.
Mississippi NCHRP 10-106 Testing Shows Repeatability of Zero-Speed Inertial Profiling
They shared that the mat behind the SDX, “takes fewer passes to get density compared to the conventional screed; less water consumption. When following a rubber-tire roller, the turn around spots are smoother and all-around marks less visible. The SDX screed also prevents less mat tear marks from the steel rollers.”
Using IC was a benefit for the O’Briens as well. They explained the system allowed them to see how many passes they’d completed and where they’d already rolled. “Just like flying an airplane at night—you know where the runway is.”
Smooth Results
With compactors working on the rolling pattern, the team could start gathering density data. They used a NoNuke density gauge from Instrotek Inc., Research Triangle Park, North Carolina, to collect 360 points—97 of those behind the screed—before rolling. They used the PaveScan 2.0 RDM from Geophysical Survey Systems Inc., Nashua, New Hampshire, to gather 19,609 DPS data points—9,932 of those behind the SDX screed. An operator from Robison Grinding & Profiling LLC, Gillette, Wyoming, drove the SSI Zero-Speed Inertial Profiler along the project’s base and surface/wear courses.
The results showed a high-quality job. Starting with the non-nuclear density gauge results, Wuori reported the average density directly behind the SDX screed was 91.5%; the average behind the traditional screed was 89.8%. Notice that’s not a bad number. The CSI paving crew was handling mix delivery and paving with best practices. But they were seeing a 1.7% density increase immediately behind the screed with the patterned plate.
AXENOX’s OXCLAW Screed System Creates Buzz in Asphalt Industry
John Fales, CSI paving superintendent on the project, said, “This paving crew is like a well-oiled machine. They take pride in the work they do every day and pave some of the best asphalt roads in the Midwest.”
The non-nuclear density gauge numbers behind the finish roller told a similar story. The CSI paving and rolling train was knocking it out of the park, achieving 93.6% average density in the traditional-screed-plate lane. They hit an average density of 94.8% in the SDX lane, which is a density increase of 1.2%.
Moving to the DPS data on the SDX section, both northbound and southbound driving lanes offered a dielectric value of 4.50 with a standard deviation of only 0.11. This converts to a density of 94-94.5%.
“To CSI’s credit, this was the lowest STD ever collected with the PaveScan DPS unit on an asphalt surface,” Wuori shared. “A decrease in standard deviation equals more consistent average densities. A lower standard deviation is better for percent-within-limit (PWL) projects and decreases the chances of lower/higher cores or dropping the average of a lot down to less of a pay factor.”
The DPS data on the traditional section, both northbound and southbound passing lanes, offered a dielectric value of 4.40 with a standard deviation of 0.15. This converts to a density of 93.5-94%.
The zero-speed inertial profile data is in Table 1 below. Wuori summarized the results, showing the driving lane average difference—with the SDX—was 25.77 with a decrease in roughness of 2.61. The passing lane average difference—with the traditional screed—was 23.26. “This shows us a 10% improvement with the SDX,” he shared.
Despite its destructive nature, the team had to take some cores—11 random cores behind the SDX screed, 11 random cores behind the traditional screed and 10 randomly along the joint. The engineers Kadramas Lee & Jackson shared that none of the cores behind the SDX screed failed and only one of the cores behind the traditional screed failed to get above the required 92%. This testing showed a 0.44% density increase behind the SDX screed.
What the pilot project on Hwy. 85 showed is the use of innovation and best practices brought a slew of data to the industry. This data proves the innovative use of the patterned screed plate, PMTP and IC can offer improved densities and a smoother ride for the taxpayer. When asphalt pavements have a solid and sound foundation, they last longer and offer not only a quality driving experience for the end user, but also a more sustainable option for agencies/owners. The use of such innovative technologies is a win all the way around.